Not like it was in the War
January 31, 2012

WWII Couple - Coby Whitmore
The above is a comment, one of many, left on a news website that shall remain unnamed under an article featuring a rather lovely lady called Amanda Prowse, who has written a novel about a young Army wife. I edited it slightly as the grammar and spelling were appalling. I wish to address it by way of reply here as the amount of people who appear to feel this way are fairly numerous. I do not usually feel compelled to answer back critics but as military partner writing is rather what I ‘am about’, I shall.
I do not need to explain that developments in technology which enable people like the above commentator to inscribe their opinions for all to see were not available in the 1940s. What I feel does warrant some explanation is that the comparisons between six month tours and a world war are hugely unfair.
First of all, everyone in Great Britain was, in some way, involved in WWII. Everyone understood what everyone else was going through. My Grandfather, who flew in the RAF in WWII would often reminisce that those years were ‘the very best time to be alive in this country’. Of course the war brought horror, much suffering and death, but the sense of community and patriotism in Great Britain was quite something to behold. If your husband or son was away fighting, sailing or flying, you had an entire community sharing your pride in him. If he went missing, was killed or injured everyone on your street knew and would surround you, almost smothering you with goodwill. “For his country” was the phrase, and although there were those who may have disagreed with the war there were not any people living here who protested in the angry or hateful manner in the way they do today. The country was united.
Wives were busy. Both my own grandmothers were in the WAAF (Women’s Auxiliary Air Force) one in munitions and the other in ops. They were part of the ‘war effort’ and each person in the country played their part, whether they were Land Girls, farmer’s wives, auxiliary servicewomen or teachers, everyone was working hard to keep the country functioning whilst the men were away.
I admire my late grandmothers more than most people I have met. I used to sit and discuss at length what it was like during the war with the youngest of the two and she would always say the same thing, that it was hard. She did not know if she would see my grandfather again. They did grab weeks together and they did write, being in the same service meant they used dead air time to speak on the radio (illegally) too. She always said that she was too busy to miss him properly. I know it was harder back then than she let on, her eyes betrayed her typically English stiff upper lip. I do not doubt that those women with literary talent would have penned their emotions in the same way the wives of today do; it is only that today it is far easier to upload those writings onto the internet and share them with the world. Back then, literary creativity was saved for the love letters posted to sweethearts.
As the partner of a service person in 2012, you are surrounded by people who have nothing to do with the military. You have a civilian job or are a mum at home and you are not part of any war effort at all; in fact you are often left feeling rather more of a hindrance than a cog in a wheel. Yes, technology has surpassed itself but you still cannot call your partner when he is deployed. He can pick up emails but this is not the case for everyone and technology is not infallible. If he is truly frontline you may not speak to him for weeks and weeks at a time, all the while you must go about your daily work as if this is completely normal whilst everyone else around you tells you about their plans with their husbands or what silly thing their boyfriend said to them last night. In a time where most normal couples barely spend a night apart and send text messages to one another throughout the day, you are faced with the same situation women endured decades ago. I was sent two letters in six months, less than one phone call every two weeks and I did not receive any emails because where he was did not have any computers.
Instead of a six year war interspersed with short breaks where they come home, modern day soldiers go away for six months at a time on a regular basis. Many regiments deploy every 2-3 years, a few go every 18 months. Some soldiers who joined in the 1990s have served a collective deployment of rather more than six years, and that away-time does not account for the few months of pre-deployment build up training where communications with partners and children are extremely limited, nor does it account for normal exercises (periods of time away training) where the same applies, which take up much of the year.
As for the partners writing? I like my whiny writing. It means I do not burst into tears in the office. It means I do not cry when someone asks me how he is or what he is doing, as they do not know. It is an outlet and a stress relief and when I am done writing I close the page or shut the notebook and get on with my life, as if all the negative feelings have been popped into a box and left behind me. Whereas in the 40′s your entire local community understood what you were going through, now partners look to the internet to speak to others in the same position and gain support. It can provide a comforting anonymity that allows a stiff upper lip to be visible in public. Some things, you see, do not change.
The other criticism that often niggles is ‘you knew what you were getting yourself in to, so stop moaning’ however, I feel I have addressed this enough in the past. Unless you are a clairvoyant or were married to a servicemen before how can you have any possible idea what it will be like? You do not pick the person you fall in love with and if you are anything like me the military is literally the last place you would choose to marry into thank you very much.
Warfare in the 21st Century is a completely different beast to that of the mid-20th Century and the way partners adapt to it has altered too. I really hoped that I would never have to point this out, but here is the simple truth; Comparisons between military wives during the war and military wives today criticising the latter are frankly ridiculous. If you do not want to read about what life is like for a military partner in today’s world, my advice is fairly straight forward; don’t. It is not any easier today than it was in the First or Second World War, it is not any harder. It is different.


I spoke with my paternal grandma last month about this very matter. Her opinion, as a WW2 wife of a pilot, was that the service families (and partners) of today have it much harder. All her children, my Aunts; Uncles and father, have been either married to or in the Forces. She has seen her 2 sons go through Cranwell and thei various training courses after. She has watched my Dad fly off to warzones and same with his brother. More recently her grandson has spent 3 out the last 7 years in middle East. She said it was heartbreaking not knowing. My Nan also said if Twitter and blogging had been around when she was a young RAF wife then she would have used them for venting. I know it’s a huge blessing for yourself and many others. Some couples, civilian couples that is, don’t realise just how lucky they are!
thank you xx
An absolutely fabulous post my lovely x No one understands what it is like being the partner of a service person these days unless you are one yourself. The feeling that you are nothing more than baggage which is an unfortunate consequence of employing this person in the military, the seeming unfairness of the way that you can be treated, unless you are part of that community, you can not understand what it is to be a military wife/partner. Well written and thought out as usual x
thanks Hel xx
This ignorant approach only goes to show how badly the present government has handled things. Technically we have been ‘at war’ since 911 whether we liked it or not. The financial problems that we face at the moment are in part down to the expense of taking on Iraq and Afghanistan and the ‘carry on and pretend it is nothing to do with us’ attitude of the majority of the genral public is beyond belief. Maybe if both this nad the previous government had been more realistic in their approaches they would have more support for their present stance. It’s time the world woke up and also high time they took some responsibility for those who have given and those who continue to give so much.
You state that comparisons are ridicululous and then compare by stating that “It is not any easier today than it was in the First or Second World War, it is not any harder!?!”
Today, military wives choose to marry their husbands and husbands choose to join the military. These facts cannot be overlooked. Conscription is no longer in place. In addition, the British soldiers are fighting an illegal war in the Middle East that, by nature of being illegal, is not going to gain 100% support of the British public despite ‘hero’ plugs. Why don’t military wives concern themselves more with discovering the truth about what their men are really putting their lives on the line for instead of obsessing with gaining as much sympathy off the public as possible?
1) I stated that “comparisons between military wives during the war and military wives today criticising the latter are frankly ridiculous” the important part of that sentence is the latter part. Please re-read it.
2) I am anti war. I was anti our occupation of Iraq. I have never professed to be pro-war. However, I support my partner in his choice (yes, choice) of career, that he made when he was 16. He is now pushing 30. I fell in love with him years ago, despite not wanting to be in a relationship with a soldier. Please re-read the penultimate paragraph. You do not choose who you fall in love with. Show me a woman who has walked away from her perfect man on the basis of his job alone and I will show you a fool.
3) They DO NOT choose where they are posted, and face imprisonment if they disobey orders. When my partner joined the forces we were not engaged in Iraq or Afghanistan, and both began during his first term of his (unbreakable) contract of service. So he was sent, and he went. So he stayed in? So what? Maybe he sees another side to his work that you or I cannot possibly understand, having never served on the frontline yourself.
4) Please read my bio and learn a little more about the woman you decide to criticise.
5) Talking about conscription is bizarre and does not support your argument. Most people volunteered to take part in both World Wars. Many volunteered underage illegally. Your point there is redundant.
6) I do not want your sympathy. I do not want anyone’s sympathy. What I want is for women in the same position as me to feel that they are not on their own and that there are others out there who ‘get it’. You can take your sympathy and use it where it is actually needed.
Please feel free to re-read my article and the bottom line. Don’t like it? Don’t seek it out. You clicked on my link, you were attracted to my article, you felt so passionately about it that you wrote a comment. Perhaps you should choose more suitable reading material to your tastes.
Hell yes! VERY well said Charlie. Fed up of people thinking Military partners are looking for sympathy and spouting FALSE ‘facts’ they think are 100% correct because it was on some news website (for example).
Beautiful piece again btw
Xx
I am not criticising you. I am not naive enough to believe for one minute that what your going through is easy. I was merely pointing out that you had a choice, unfortunately the orphans in the Middle East did not and their voices go unheard the most.
Conscription is entirely relevant. Men of fighting age during WW1&2 had no choice. Those that decided not to fight were jailed and shot for cowardice. Men/boys today have a choice and it isn’t unknown (unless you struggle thinking and buy into the media lies far too much) that joining the military means you may be called to war, lose a limb or die in your uniform.
Why would you support someone for doing something you are anti? He chose to stay in, therefore he appears not to be considering your feelings. What should mean more, your partner or your occupation?
I have not served on the front-line. I have, however, spoken to ex-soldiers and seen for myself the psychological damage their service has caused. The fact they were subjected to (and perpetrators of) such atrocities is ignored by the media that is so intent in glamorising war. Parades, medals, choir songs, constant advertisements = Propaganda.
Do your husbands know what they are putting their lives on the line for? Do you know what you are living in fear for? If either answer is no…?????
I suggest by your style of writing that you have made it a personal decision to choose to ignore the good work the Armed Forces do across the world and here in the UK (or haven’t bothered to research what they actually do aside from orphan the children of Taliban fighters). This means you are not capable of reasoned debate on the subject. You only see one side.
As to the reason that I do not have a hissy fit and demand my partner leave his job ‘for me’, the reason is that he chooses to do his job and I support him. It is called love. If he told me he didn’t want me to be a lawyer because he found defending people morally reprehensible I would tell him to shove his opinion up his arse and carry on anyway. A person who makes those sort of demands is not someone I would ever want to be with, so why should I be that person for him?
My partner is a fantastic soldier. He is one of the best in the world at what he does, and incredibly experienced. He cannot abide cruelty in any form. He thinks that some parts of the human race are abhorrent for the atrocities they are capable of committing upon one another, on animals and our environment, and he has witnessed these atrocities first hand. Perhaps, dare I say it, he knows a little more about humanity than you do. He definitely knows more about the good the military do than you.
Stop judging people without actually knowing both sides of the story. You have formed your opinions through what you have read and through cherry picking who you have made contact with to substantiate the negative views you already held.
Actual experience of what the military do v experience formulated by what you have read and who you have spoken to…. I think we can see who the hypocrite is here
“I suggest by your style of writing that you have made it a personal decision to choose to ignore the good work the Armed Forces do across the world and here in the UK (or haven’t bothered to research what they actually do aside from orphan the children of Taliban fighters). This means you are not capable of reasoned debate on the subject. You only see one side”.
You are from a military family with a soldier for a partner yet it is only me that sees one side? That is hypocritical.
As for soldiers knowing more about humanity…they kill people in a uniform. Humans are not natural killers…British soldiers train to kill. Where is the humanity in that?
Ever heard of the (paraphrased) saying that the first loser in debate is he who makes it personal? You just lost.
99% of HM Forces never take a life in their entire career. You clearly have absolutely no idea what you are talking about.
Yes, I was born into the military. Yes, my sibling is in the military. You don’t know what they did or what they do, so your argument is redundant. They could have been surgeons or padres. Yes, my partner is in the military. He takes lives, but he saves them far more frequently.
Why does my birth, my family and my partner corrupt my view? It gives me insight but my views are my own. My mother, who served for 22 years, gets more upset about poor MOD decisions than you could possibly comprehend – because she actually understands BOTH sides of the situation.
I have no further desire to speak to silly militant pacifist keyboard warriors. If you spent more of your time researching both sides of an argument as well as the art of debate and less time relying on other people’s quotes to make your poorly articulated points you might be more interesting to talk to.
Wow! Brilliant … just Brilliant! The most powerful thing I’ve read for ages.
thank you!
Liza. I am not military nor from a military family. As I understand it when our soldiers signed up (whatever the correct term is for joining be army) they undertook to go where they are sent by the government- they do not get to pick and choose. Supporting our brave forces & the families waiting for them is not he same as supporting the war.
To some extent I think being at home today must be harder than WW 1 & 2. The news channels beam the horrors of war home for the families to see as a constant reminder.
I don’t understand your logic…the soldiers are the war!?!
Nothing will end war unless the people themselves refuse to go to war.
~Albert Einstein
Last sentence of paragraph 3 is something I regularly point out to people who criticize British Operations overseas.
@liza
The only people who I feel can make informed, accurate decisions on the true nature of what we are doing there, are the people who have actually been there, lived it 24/7 for months at a time and deal with it every day.
Not people who choose to spend a few minutes of their day reading a news article or the negative/positive views of someone else then carry on with their lives.
Had you been there and served yourself; seen the positive affects of the work you’re carrying out and you still disagree then fair enough. I’d listen to you and take your points in to consideration. Until then, I feel your argument remains invalid.
I came across your blog when searching out information about Military girlfriends when my boyfriend made the decision that in the near future he will be joining the Army here in the US. I went all the way back to your very first post and started reading…I have loved every single post because you talk about true and real emotions, how you feel and what the two of you go through together. I don’t feel that any of it is truly “whining” it’s expressing sincere emotion. I think the fact that military spouses/girlfriends/boyfriends/siblings/family members in general take the time to write about what they’re going through so that people who are about to have or are currently having the same experience…well I think they’re fantastic! I had no clue what to expect from him joining up and it terrified me, the things you’ve written, while about the military in a different country, have still given me some insight into what I can expect to go through. You see, what you are doing here is wonderful and I admire you for it.
Just because you choose to do something does not make it easy. Only those who have experienced the life of the military partner can truly comment on it. Since my OH is deployed in the coming months I thank my lucky stars that I have friends and family who may not fully understand , but who will support me and my children unconditionally….unlike some who have posted here
Again, very well expressed opinion!
Of course a further comparison is that of todays Reservist, who also experiences the dislocation of family life, combined with the removal of their “routine” of civilian employment, and the added complication/concern of what happens to their working life while they are away, and what will happen when they return!
As the increasing deployment lengths impact their career, and even when they return (not usually as “heroes”), they are thrust straight back to work, with no ready access to the Support network of their Military colleagues, surrounded by civilians who love war stories, but can’t relate to the experiences.
As a partner of an RAF officer and myself serving in Her majesty’s forces I find comments like Lizas very distressing. I didn’t join the military to hurt anyone, I did it because I wanted to protect my country. As cheesy as it is, I grew up nicknamed mother hen because I just wanted to protect everyone and now I do it as a job, I couldn’t imagine if this was taken away from me. My partner and I don’t hurt anyone or wish to be at war, we deploy at different times so it’s very difficult but we do it because we love each other and we love our jobs. We didn’t start this war but we both dedicated ourselves to serve in her majesty’s force and if afghan is what that job requires to rid this world of terror and to make it even a little safer a world to bring my children into then that’s good enough for me. I’m not asking you to support the war, just support us, look after our partners at home and remember those who won’t ever get to come home to their families or support those who come home half the man they were when they left! We do it for you!
Why is my comment distressing? I have an alternative point of view…that is life.
“We didn’t start this war but we both dedicated ourselves to serve in her majesty’s force and if afghan is what that job requires to rid this world of terror and to make it even a little safer a world to bring my children into then that’s good enough for me”.
The above quote suggests you do not have a clue about what the war is about. War is terror.
Oh I’m sorry, I didn’t realise you’d been to a war zone, my mistake, you’re clearly a higher authority on warfare than I am. You distress me as you tar the military with the brush of the media. There are TWO sides, defence and attack.
If you want to get personal and tell me my job isn’t fit for purpose, tell me what it is exactly that YOU do to make the world a better place, what do you do to make a difference?
Brilliant. Times have changed, as everything in life does.
Like you said, if you don’t like it don’t read it! Especially when you have no idea.
Yes they had a choice in the beginning. And yes we have to accept it. But that definitely doesn’t mean we have to like it!
I love reading your blogs, they made me realise I’m not the only one going crazy!
I’m also going to buy the book mentioned. No doubt will have me in tears & bring back a few memories (I just about it)
Thank you
Oops, and I’m not asking for sympathy there! Haha
definitely not the only one going crazy, that I can promise you… we are all going crazy together
@Liza – I was one of those on the streets protesting against our troops being sent to Iraq. I was angry, like you. I still am, like you. Unlike you, however, I am able to comprehend the difference between those who are sent and those who do the sending. The former have little choice but to go where they are sent, do the best they can and if necessary to die in the attempt. In return, the latter agree only to invoke the requirement when absolutely unavoidable. That’s the covenant, between our government and our forces, signed in good faith by military people of every stripe and adhered to regardless of the personal cost. If you can’t agree with the original choice, you must surely respect the commitment.
For the record, I am angry because this sacred covenant was abused for political expediency in the rush to invade Iraq and settle old scores. Your ire, however, appears to be directed in entirely the wrong direction. Have you been writing hateful messages to Blair? Bush? Somehow I doubt it. You talked about orphans (which, by the way was cynical and offensive). Where is your heart for the hundreds of widows and fatherless children these conflicts have created in the UK? Where is your compassion for those in this country who live day to day not knowing if their partner will live or die? Walk away?! What nonsense. Love is love.
Here’s another angle – Afghanistan. If our forces refused to follow orders, ask yourself how much safer the women and children of Afghanistan would be? Or perhaps go and see for yourself – but be careful. It’s a fatal place for women, Afghanistan. I am hugely proud of our forces for every tiny improvement they can effect in the lives of these ordinary women and children, for whom it is a way of life to be subject to every whim of husbands, brothers, fathers, uncles et al; whims which regularly cost women their lives and orphan – yes, orphan – their children.
This blog is honest, real and overflowing with humanity. If you really can’t allow that simple expression of another’s joys and sorrows without leaping to judgement, condemnation and spite, I fear for your humanity. And I hope you never have to look to a soldier to preserve your life. S/he won’t give two hoots about your opinions and will only care about the job – save this life. You, however, will have to refuse the assistance…
I really enjoy reading your blog, always honest and from the heart. People will always hate what they do not understand, often through fear and the influence of others around them. keep up the good work!!!
thank you very much Sylvie x